Categories
Philosophy

[01] Disinformation Dynamics: A Relational Framework for Persistent Communicative Organisation

01-DD

A prediction fails. A reply treats the failure as evidence of concealment. A later claim about a different event draws on the same distinction between trusted witness and suspected authority. How does that relationship persist through these changes, and what does its persistence make possible next?

Relations are logically prior to the identities they distinguish. Speakers, audiences and institutions acquire recognisable roles through their interactions. These roles are provisional. A witness can become a critic, a source can lose authority, and a change of platform can alter who encounters whose response. Persistence concerns the relations that remain consequential through such changes.

Relational Configuration and Time

Communication establishes, maintains or modifies temporal relations between processes. Field Logic treats time as the finite propagation of relation. A claim occurs, reaches different participants and becomes consequential at different times. Record occurrence, reception and response separately where the evidence permits. The interval between a publication and a reply is an observed lag. The interval between reception and reply concerns a different dependency. See system time.

A relational configuration is a description of the dependencies relevant to a particular inquiry. In the failed prediction example it includes which claim was challenged, which response interpreted the challenge as concealment, and which later exchanges took up that interpretation. The configuration can retain earlier events whose effects are still arriving. Its boundaries follow the relations being investigated and can be revised as those relations change.

Recurrence and Recursive Change

Recurrence is the return of a specified pattern. Feedback occurs when the consequences of activity return to influence further activity. The dynamics are recursive when what happens at one stage enters the conditions governing the next. A pattern becomes self-propagating when its activity favours recurrence of the relations through which it arose.

Let Sn be the configuration at step n, including the history required by the description. Let Pn be the transition rule in force at that step. The rule assigns probabilities to possible successors. The realised transition enters the update of the rule.

Sn+1 ∼ Pn(· | Sn)
Pn+1 = Φ(Pn, Sn, Sn+1)

The first line gives the distribution from which the next configuration is drawn. In the second, Φ specifies how the present rule and the realised transition determine the updated rule. A quantitative model requires a defined set of possible configurations and a justified update. The logical orbit names the constitutive incompleteness of local configurations. Each depends on relations that its current expression cannot exhaust. The reconstruction of those dependencies through activity is recursive displacement.

A Criterion for Persistence

Specify what must continue and which transformations the criterion admits. An exact invariant I satisfies I(T(S)) = I(S) for each specified transformation T of the configuration S in its domain. An empirical criterion states the variation it allows. In the example, the relation between challenge and reinterpretation can remain recognisable across different wording, participants and channels. The criterion must distinguish that continuity from a new sequence with a similar appearance.

Let Cn be the event that the criterion has held through step n, including the conditions required between recorded steps. The conditional probability qn gives the chance of continuity through the next step, given continuity so far.

qn = Pr(Cn+1 | Cn)

Continuity through a later step entails continuity through each earlier step. Starting with Pr(C0) = 1, the chain rule gives the following result whenever the conditioning events have positive probability.

Pr(CN) = q0 × q1 × ⋯ × qN−1

Each factor conditions on continuity up to that point. The product concerns the full interval. To test self-propagation, compare continuity under the proposed feedback mechanism with continuity under comparable conditions where that mechanism differs. Shared news events, established relationships and ordinary cycles of activity are possible sources of recurrence that such a comparison must consider.

Phase, Coupling and Harmonic Structure

Phase is position within a defined cycle. Coupling specifies how the state of one process enters the evolution of another. Reciprocal influence can be asymmetric, with different effects in each direction. Algebraic antisymmetry is more specific. For two cyclic phases θ1 and θ2, define an oriented quantity by the sine of their difference.

A(θ1, θ2) = sin(θ2 − θ1)
A(θ2, θ1) = −A(θ1, θ2)

A common shift of both phases preserves A. Exchanging the phases reverses its sign. A coupling law specifies what that quantity does in the dynamics. The oscillator construction in How Things Persist shows how reciprocal coupling can sustain a phase difference while both phases advance.

In Fourier analysis, harmonics of a periodic signal have frequencies at positive integer multiples of its fundamental frequency. The handbook uses harmonic structure more broadly for recurrent timing and coupling across scales, including cycles that share no common period. A formal application specifies the measured activity, the cycles or frequency bands under examination and the evidence for their interaction.

Uncertainty and Physical Cost

For a chosen observation interval, define a finite set of mutually exclusive and exhaustive outcomes for the next response. If their probabilities are p1, …, pm, their Shannon entropy in bits is given by the following expression (Shannon, 1948).

H = −∑j=1m pj log2(pj)

A zero probability contributes zero. With m equally probable outcomes, H = log2(m). Unequal probabilities give a lower entropy for the same set of outcomes. The measure concerns uncertainty about the chosen variable under the stated conditions.

Maintaining a communicative pattern requires work from participants, institutions and technical infrastructure. A physical account of entropy production specifies the system boundary, irreversible processes and exchanges of energy and matter. An account of communicative persistence follows how the constraints and costs of maintaining a pattern are distributed. See order and entropy.

Evidence and Intervention

Accurate reporting, honest error and deliberate deception participate in the same dynamics of recurrence and response. Assess accuracy and intent from evidence about the communication and its circumstances. Assess persistence from evidence about which dependencies are renewed and how that renewal changes subsequent activity.

Control is always provisional. A correction, classification or change in access becomes another event within the relations under study. Its effects alter the conditions for subsequent communication and for further intervention. The chapter on recursive harmonics takes up the mathematical description of recurrence and coupling.

References

Shannon, C.E. (1948) ‘A mathematical theory of communication’, Bell System Technical Journal, 27(3), pp. 379–423. doi: 10.1002/j.1538-7305.1948.tb01338.x.

Comments Closed

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *